| Awesome | 18 | Devon, Chuck, Sarah, Ellie |
| Stay in the Car/Van/Table/Out of the Way/Bar/House/Inside/Here/Store | 17 | Sarah, Casey |
| Chuck | 13 | Everybody |
| Chuck, Are You OK | 10 | Sarah |
| I'm Sorry | 8 | Chuck, Sarah, Lazlo. Lou |
| Trust Me | 8 | Sarah, Chuck |
| Are you OK/Alright | 6 | Morgan, Chuck, Ellie |
| Did You Just Flash? | 6 | Sarah |
| It's Complicated | 5 | Chuck |
| I Know | 4 | Chuck |
| Pineapple | 4 | Chuck, Jeff, Morgan |
| Now is not the time/Concentrate on the Mission | 4 | Sarah, Casey, Carina |
| Don't Freak Out | 4 | Sarah, Chuck |
| I'm Freaking Out | 3 | Chuck, Lou |
| Kill Him (I'll Kill You); I'll end you | 3 | Langston, Casey, Chuck |
| What? | 3 | Sarah, Chuck, Casey |
| You did OK (you did really good) | 2 | Casey, Sarah |
| Aces (Charles, Aces) | 2 | Ellie |
| I've Seen the Way (He) She looks at you, She doesn't know it yet; Whatever you say | 2 | Ellie, Carina, Casey |
| You Are My/Our Only Hope | 2 | Morgan, Lazlo |
| What's Your Favorite Band? | 1 | Chuck |
| I think we should break up | 1 | Chuck |
| You're Everything I Ever Hoped For | 1 | Chuck |
| Friends? | 1 | Chuck, Sarah |
| Normal Life | 1 | Sarah |
| Hero | 1 | Sarah |
| You did it | 1 | Sarah |
| We're going to have to talk about what happened | 1 | Sarah |
| What happened was a mistake. One which will not happen again. | 1 | Sarah |
| Get the secrets out of my/your head | 1 | Sarah, Chuck |